Max Volbers’ new Album “Bach vs. Scheibe“ (September 2025)

On September 5, Berlin Classics released Max Volbers’ latest album, “Bach vs. Scheibe,” featuring Concerto Köln and soprano Marie-Sophie Pollak, for which he is the artistic director.

In the album, the orchestra takes up a dispute that started in 1737 between Danish music critic Johann Adolf Scheibe and none other than Johann Sebastian Bach. In his magazine “Der Critische Musicus,” Scheibe called Bach’s compositions “confused and pompous.” Bach’s response was not long in coming, and so a dispute ensued that lasted for years.

Thus, this album not only contains the music of two contemporaries, but also shows the transition from the High Baroque to the Classical period and is an expression of an aesthetic generational conflict.